Seeking a One

The Hunt

By Debra KaminAug. 17, 2023

After a few years of renting in Brooklyn, a young couple combed through listings in Cobble Hill, Brooklyn Heights and Boerum Hill. Here’s where they landed.

Mat and Taylor Batts got their first taste of city life as newlyweds in 2015, when they moved into an apartment in downtown Winston-Salem, N.C. The couple, who met at the University of North Carolina Wilmington, were excited to be on their own in a walkable area that buzzed with life.

Mr. Batts had grown up in the exurbs of Winston-Salem. After college he briefly played minor league baseball. Ms. Batts, an elementary school teacher, spent much of her childhood in Raleigh, N.C. After college, the couple would take the occasional trip to New York City, and they realized they shared a desire to live there.

Mr. Batts recalled their first visit, when they arrived by train during the Christmas season. “I remember coming out of Penn Station, and just looking around and being like, ‘Oh, my God, what is this?’” he said.

“Moving to New York was always that dream,” Ms. Batts said.

[Did you recently buy a home? We want to hear from you. Email: [email protected]]

In 2018, they decided they would apply for jobs in New York, and if they got them, they would pack up their two dogs — Winnie, a golden retriever, and Winston, a doodle mix — and live the dream.

Ms. Batts scored first, landing a position at a charter school in Brooklyn for the 2019-20 school year. Mr. Batts found a job as a copywriter for a Brooklyn company soon after. With the dogs in mind, they opted not just to work in Brooklyn, but to live there as well, because of the many dog parks and the dog-friendly feeling.

The couple, now both 32, landed in a studio in Downtown Brooklyn, and then upgraded to a two-bedroom in Brooklyn Heights that was affordable thanks to a pandemic rent reduction. The rent started at $3,180 a month and then rose to $3,250 the second year. By the summer of 2022, the prospect of a sharper rent hike loomed.

“We knew the rent would go up the third year, so we felt if we could find something with a similar monthly payment, it might be worth it,” Mr. Batts said.

He had recently received a gift from his parents that could be applied to a down payment. The couple calculated that with 20 percent down, they could afford to buy an apartment for around $650,000 without blowing their monthly budget.

As they started searching, they had plenty to learn about the New York housing market. “We knew nothing about the process,” Mr. Batts said. “Nothing about the difference between co-ops and condos.”

But they did know what they wanted: a small, older Brooklyn building with character and history.

“I am so gung-ho about this area,” Ms. Batts said. “I wanted something that felt like a quintessential New York brownstone.”

They don’t plan to have children, so they searched for one-bedroom apartments within walking distance of a park for their dogs. They enlisted the help of Sarah Minton, a licensed real estate agent with Compass, who understood the challenges they would face.

Having “two dogs is always an extra hurdle in New York, because so many buildings have breed restrictions, weight restrictions and number-of-pet restrictions,” Ms. Minton said. “Mat and Taylor really liked the brownstone vibe, and those buildings tend to have way more restrictions around pets.”

The couple began hunting last summer. Among their options:

No. 1

Prewar Charm in Brooklyn Heights

An abundance of light and closet space made an impression in this third-floor co-op apartment in tree-lined Brooklyn Heights, three blocks from Cadman Plaza Park. The couple loved the oversized bedroom and the quaint foyer, as well as the high ceilings, hardwood floors and old-fashioned tub. But the kitchen felt dated and cramped, and with a $625,000 asking price and about $1,050 a month in maintenance fees, the apartment was at the top of their budget.

No. 2

Renovated Kitchen in Boerum Hill

This first-floor unit in a five-story prewar co-op building felt dark when the couple first saw it, and it had been on the market for several months, which made them wary. But they liked the renovated kitchen with ample counter space and the building’s landscaped roof deck, which had gas grills and skyline views. Still, there weren’t many green spaces close by. The apartment was priced at $585,000, with monthly maintenance of about $965.

No. 3

Skyline Views in Cobble Hill

This corner unit on the top floor of a six-story walk-up condominium building had views for miles, although the stairs gave them pause, as did the rumble of the Brooklyn-Queens Expressway nearby. But they knew the dogs would love the building’s central courtyard, and the in-unit washer and dryer were a major plus. The price was $699,000, with about $1,000 a month in taxes and fees, and a $500 monthly assessment through December 2023.

Find out what happened next by answering these two questions:

Which Would You Choose?

Prewar Charm in Brooklyn Heights

Renovated Kitchen in Boerum Hill

Skyline Views in Cobble Hill

Which Did They Buy?

Prewar Charm in Brooklyn Heights

Renovated Kitchen in Boerum Hill

Skyline Views in Cobble Hill